HITLER SKINS MINECRAFT SKIN
The large leap of reasoning from "defended judge's choice to use a hilter skin in minecraft" to "Yakman is defending Hitler" is highly Godwinian. I was far closer to being right than you or phinq, and it appears you agree. You are right, it doesn't strictly fit the interpretation espoused on wikipedia and I knew this when I made the comment, because it is close enough. Godwin's law is satisfied when someone accuses the other party of defending Nazism with no justification whatsoever.Īccording to wikipedia it needs to be an inappropriate accusation, and I feel this was entirely appropriate.Īlso, it's not a real law, more a joke some guy said one time.ĭoes it say something about mentioning Godwin's law as also satisfying the law? I don't follow you here. Godwin's law itself can be abused as a distraction, diversion or even as censorship, fallaciously miscasting an opponent's argument as hyperbole when the comparisons made by the argument are actually appropriate. I don't feel Phinq saying you're defending Hitler is comparing you to Hitler.Ī sub rule to this appears to be that it's frowned upon for someone to unjustly point out Godwin's rule. The essence of Godwin's law is that the longer a discussion continues, the more likely someone is to compare their opponent or their views to Hitler and Nazism. I've changed my opinion from the insightful wikipedia article you listed and now think that Godwin's law wasn't in play until you mentioned it. Honestly I would like if you could explain what alternative interpretation of Godwin's law you have where this particular point in the discussion does not stand out as the only Godwinian momement. There is no other point in the discussion before this that involves a leap of reasoning to claim that someone is somehow in support of Nazism or Hilter. This is clearly very far from the essence of Godwin's law, so I don't see why people are struggling to understand that Godwin's law was first satisfied in this thread when Phinq said I am "defending Hitler".
The alternative interpretation of the law you seem to be supporting is that any historical or social discussion of Hilter or Nazism immediately satisfy Godwin's law and is therefore stupid and should not proceed. The natural generalization of Godwin's law(if this isn't already implicitly obvious from the law itself) to discussions which already involve Hilter as a topic is that Godwin's law is satisfied when someone accuses the other party of defending Nazism with no justification whatsoever. Obviously Godwin did not intend to say that any discussion involving Nazism is stupid or not worth while. The essence of Godwin's law is to point out how stupid it is to try to win an argument by accusing the other party of supporting or emulating Nazi views given little to no justification.
He was a guy who always gave people a chance and wasn't afraid to be himself. In remembrance of VanillaPockyFox, an outstanding member of a great community. Thank you to the community, old and new, for being great people and providing a great place to have so much fun at. There have already been lots of great times to thank you for, with only more to come. Thank you to all current and retired staff of HCFactions.
HITLER SKINS MINECRAFT MODS
(Minecraft Version 1.12.2)ĭiscord Server: Allowed Mods (1.12.2): Minecraft Forge Optifine ToggleSprint/ToggleSneak GammaBright Xaero's Mini Map LabyMod Honorable Mentions: Wayvernia Rules: Subreddit Rules Server Rules Tutorials: Hardcore Factions: Explained Subclaiming: Explained HCF vs Vanilla Minecraft Palace: Explained Resources: Contact the Staff HCFactions World Map Minecraft Server Status Buy HCF ranks, lives and more! HCFactions Store Connect: It was a good run with a great community. This subreddit remains to keep the legacy of HCF stored safely. © and ® go to the Shotbow Network, who used to host this server. Welcome to HCF, the original hardcore factions server that is based on deathbans, daily competitive events and raiding for over 5 years!ĭisclaimer: This server no longer exists.